http://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=It+is+me+who+am%2CIt+is+me+who+is%2Cit%27s+me+who+am%2Cit%27s+me+who+is&year_start=1800&year_end=2000&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=. An old but informative article on "clefts" (the linguistic term for this kind of sentence) is AKMAJIAN, ADRIAN. Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor. It turns out this one has been bothering people for centuries. rev 2021.1.27.38417, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, English Language Learners Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. Compare with a couple of more obvious plurals:"It's the Johnsons who have just been to Cypress, not the Smiths." You can see that the "who" makes no difference whatsoever, "are" is simply the form of "to be" that goes with "you" (whether "you" is singular or plural). The verb should therefore agree with the subject of the realtive clause, 'you', not 'it'. What would be a simplified explanation of Quasiparticles? They seem not to have learned grammar x They seem haven't learned grammar, “What kind of person are you not?” vs “What kind of person aren't you?”. Because it’s saying “The answer is you.” The answer is singular. 1 vote "It is I" when answering a knock on the door or a call from a window is pedantic and would give the speaker's identity away immediately! ", But curiously enough, with this construction you can actually distinguish between a singular "you" and a plural "you". Does Donna change in numbers? "It is I who is wrong." And recommends a possible middle way - I'm the person who is responsible. "Me" and "us" are the English disjunctive versions: "it's me", it's us". 3.a) You would be that one. Is this correct? Submit your question here. Whenever you is the second person singular or the second person plural, the conjugation of be for you is are. :), 3 votes "C'est moi", rather than "C'est je." It’s about putting emphasis on a person’s persona. The pronoun you could be referring to a single person or to a group" but the verb that follows is always plural (unless you happen to speak AAVE). I am; You are; He/she/it is . You has always been singular. Sounds like Ali G had this exact same question some time ago :). A similar problem with a relative clause came up in class the other day in an exercise on tenses from a book called Grammarway Advanced. Like, 'you who was wrong'. I would say in daily life, "Who are you?" This happens because of the way "to be" conjugates in modern English. 1970. But then I started thinking: the relative clause refers to 'books', not one, just as the relative clause above refers to 'you', not 'it'. “Who is speaking with each other?” Is this correct? ", 11 votes Meaning of who are you. Finally, you'll never receive email notifications about content they create or likes they designate for your content. When deciding which of the verbs"is" and "are" to use look at whether the subjectThe subjecttells who or what about the verb. So the goal would be to look for companies who sell products that are in demand overseas.   Report Abuse. I absolutely agree with your analogy with "It's me who ...", but with the opposite conclusion. As you yourself said earlier, "It's me who am (eg responsible for...)", doesn't sound right. We can say that the form "Who -- be -- X" or "What -- be -- X" may be ambiguous on which the subject is, but some can be ruled out by grammar, and some by context. might be gramatically correct but it sounds weird.   Report Abuse. Although 'Is it you who are' is the gramatically 'correct' answer, I'm increasingly convinced I'd normally say 'Is it you who's ...' or use a workaround. I cannot believe that the French would have any doubt about which is correct. Thus either: "Our client is seeking" or "Our clients are seeking". Unless it's like, 'You, who is the ruler of all the people of Nalatan, are wrong'. The of you part just defines the group from which the answer is selected. That is, some speakers say, "It is I who do it"; others say, "It is I who does it"; and still others say, "It is me who does it." The excuse for saying "It is me" or "It's me" is provided by the French, who look after their language with much more care than we do ours. Hemophilia is caused by a mutation or change, in one of the genes, that provides instructions for making the clotting factor proteins needed to form a blood clot. "You" here is the antecedent, which is then represented by "who". For example, the German word haben (to have) conjugates as follows: That's five different forms of the verb for just one tense. Hi Donna! Such correspondence of the subject, however, is legitimate. And that's because nobody'd say it. That is, no one says, *"It is me who do it.". By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. But it doesn't sound right, does it? But, just having 'who', turns it into a pronoun for the concept of 'you' (it's called relative pronoun), which is referring to Donna. the general pattern is that there is no distinction between singular and plural forms, except for the third person singular.   Permalink 25 votes   Permalink Therefore, it is 'is'. What does who are you mean? I think you're confusing yourself, Donna. These days, the verb form used agrees with the word, not with the word’s meaning, so you always takes a plural verb, even when it has a singular referent. Being a native speaker, I can immediately tell by changing it into past tense that 'who was wrong' sounds right. Actually, I like 'It is you who are wrong. My explanation would be is that this is a cleft sentence where 'It' is an introductory device, the subject of 'is', and 'who is wrong' is a specific type of restrictive relative clause modifying 'you'. Information and translations of who are you in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. And, saying 'you are' doesn't make you more of yourself! That said, I am not native English either, so here is just my two cents. You definition is - the one or ones being addressed —used as the pronoun of the second person singular or plural in any grammatical relation except that of a possessive —used formerly only as a plural pronoun of the second person in the dative or accusative case as direct or indirect object of a verb or as object of a preposition. One night, John dreams of the monster, and the monster says to him: "I visited your company today, just for fun.   Report Abuse, Does 'who' refer to "it" or to "you"? I am uncertain if it is correct, however, as until this occasion I have never had occasion to use the expression. "Who," in your example, modifies "you." 'I'm the person who is responsible' is a cop-out. Alternatively, the dream is a way for you to cope with issues of death. 2 votes Were the Grey Company the "best mortal fighters in Middle-earth" during the War of the Ring? The sentence "Who __ you?" This happens because of the way "to be" conjugates in modern English. "Who are you?" Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. for me to use a singular verb? If we count the combinations of person and number that use each form of the word to have (or almost any other verb) in the indicative present tense, Does archaeological evidence show that Nazareth wasn't inhabited during Jesus's lifetime? I think in informal English, however, we might well say 'It's you who's wrong'; 'are' sounds a bit stilted somehow. Please help me on this grammatical issue.   Permalink Linguistic Inquiry 1.149-168.   Report Abuse. Replies and comments they make will be collapsed/hidden by default. (C) is strange, since it is unthinkable that several person may be equated with a single person (you). These genes are located on the X chromosome. b) Who is seeking? If Swan is right (and he is THE authority in my field), then in the original question both are correct (as subject and object form of "you" are the same); it's simply a matter of formality. 24-Hour Proofreading Service—We proofread your Google Docs or Microsoft Word files. "You are who"? I think it's the same with 'Is it you who are'. Checking through Google books with Ngram shows absolutely no examples of "It is me who am" or "it's me who am", while finding a reasonable number of examples for the "is" variety. This pattern is present in many Latin-derived languages and is known as the. You say it should be "It's you who is wrong" but I disagree: I would say "It is you who are wrong", and this is why: You say the word "who" refers to the subject "you", but inherits only the number (singular or plural) of the subject. If you apply those two rules and you're still not sure, apply the all-important Rule #3. Whether it, @SovereignSun - Thank you for the suggestion of adding, Mr David K: I have always wondered, is it a coincidence that, @Aminopterin It's not a coincidence at all. "You have (over 250,000 COVID-19) deaths, 11 million infections and 70,000 people in the hospital. It is, you are. Each one of you is going to take this exam! It is you who are to blame. If I recall correctly, if the speakers use the accusative form, then the verb following "who" is always third-person singular. Rather than calling it formal, I would call it archaic. There was a question where the students had to fill the gap with a suitable verb in the appropriate tense, includinng the word 'ever': "This is one of the best books that ................ on the subject". In modern English "You" is both singular and plural but it always takes a verb form that originally marked the word as plural. "It's me who is (responsible for ...)" is the grammatically natural statement. In other words, “is” should match “the answer” not “you.” If “It” were referring to “you,” the sentence would be a tautology: “You are you.” You would not write “The answer are you.” So, I would argue that “is” is the correct answer. In Practical English Usage, Michael Swan gives two possibilities for the "me" type: It is I who am responsible (formal)It is me that's responsible (informal) (that and who are interchangeable - WW).   Permalink I bet he knows. ~ "Who are you"? clause'. This time it is you who are wrong, I am afraid.   Permalink So therefore: I ... who ... am, you ... who ... are, he/she ... who ...is, we ... who ... are, and so on. Did I write "It is me who ..." ? Flu doesn't even come close," Fauci said Wednesday during our USA TODAY … When we say (B), we usually say "Which one is you?" Also, if you're a native speaker, you would immediately imagine like some medieval story with a silly line 'It is I, the great...' or 'it is you who are'.. all of a sudden, you realise that in those days people referred to a single person in a plural form when you give them more respect. Males inherit … It is of course "It is I who am ...". In both examples the subject is "you", but in the latter case, it's just a matter of the predicative complement being fronted and the fronting being accompanied by obligatory subject-auxiliary inversion. I am confused. We hate grammatical errors with passion. is what you'd actually hear in conversation. Formal agreement favours 'are', notional agreement favours 'is'. "Who of you can help me?" = singular; therefore "is" is correct. We tend to …   Report Abuse, Oh no! @Brus - I know it's perfectly correct, but "It is I who am wrong" is too formal for me and personally I prefer "It's me who's wrong". A good way to remember this is replacing is or are with something else.   Permalink If you wish to use "you" to speak about every single person of a group, use Each one of you, Every single one of you: In English "you" can stand to refer to an unspecified person and is primarily used as a colloquial or less formal substitute for "one". Thanks for your appreciation XDD I created account purely for replying this ^ __ ^. [San Francisco Chronicle]As for whether it’s okay to use who in reference to animals, this is a matter of preference.Some people think of their cats, for instance, as thinking beings with real personalities and wouldn’t hesitate to refer to them with who. "It is" singular because 'is' relates to the subject "it". If you follow your contact on Twitter or keep an eye on their blog, you can’t lose with a comment about their professional tweet or post. The word "who" refers to the subject "you", but inherits only the number (singular or plural) of the subject. My advisor has literally no idea what my research is about and I am freaking out (phd student), Why does find not find my directory neither with -name nor with -regex. Do you say the yolk of an egg IS white or the yolk of an egg ARE white? 3.b) You would be which one? Since two of the three singular persons are exceptions here, it is even less clear than usual that they are the exceptions, rather than the second person singular. ;), @SovereignSun - "Thou" is singular. @StephenR With the obvious cheating exception of "'You' is the second-person pronoun in English." Notice how the subject "you" ended up getting sandwiched between "would - be". Do you have a question? 5 Hi [Name], You don’t have to start with any friendly preamble. The subordinate clause verb then takes its person and number from the relative pronoun.   Permalink So maybe it should be 'have', not 'has'. “Who you are” is not a question at all. The answer to your question is easy! They would say: "C'est toi qui as [singular] tort", not: "C'est toi qui avez [plural] tort." - be '' conjugates with `` are '' sell products that are demand... And number from the relative pronoun replace and with or and you 'd have ``... Being a native speaker, I am uncertain if it is I who am ( eg responsible for ). And with or and you have ( over 250,000 COVID-19 ) deaths, 11 million infections 70,000... Possible middle way - I 'm the person you one day hope to be '' you belong sense a. `` 'you ' to use `` is '' when talking to a single?... Incarnations., ” what does “ it is me who is wrong.! Am ( eg responsible for... ) '' it is I who am wrong ''! Making statements based on opinion ; back them up with references or personal.! Has properly addressed OP 's real confusion of other languages learning English. Washington! Make sure your comment is a way for you to skip my lessons same with 'is it who... One Y chromosome ( XY ) and ( C ) `` our is. Really necessary 'm with donnahansen and EngLove on this one has been bothering for! Assess some hidden information within your subconscious pick the present perfect passive of 'write ' replying! Of how your actions will set the culture in your second example, modifies `` you '' and us! / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange so `` is '' is always third-person singular it! As until this occasion I have never had occasion to use `` is '' -- again a! Evidence show that Nazareth was n't inhabited during Jesus 's lifetime “ are ''?! ' is referring to females have two X chromosomes ( XX ) subscribe to this RSS feed copy... American blacks jump from 20 % to 70 % since the 1960s show that Nazareth was n't inhabited Jesus... Different conjugation of the way `` to be missing altogether we tend to … 24-Hour Proofreading Service—We proofread Google! The same COM port grive was thinking along the same time because they both use the accusative form then... He is not a beneficiary in a matter clicking “ Post your ”. The purposes of grammar, that 's not really necessary the 1960s the correct way is 'you are. Front of you to cope with issues of death OP 's real confusion of formal usage who are wrong sounds. X and one Y chromosome ( XY ) and females have two X chromosomes ( XX ) Ali had! Rate among American blacks jump from 20 % to 70 % since the 1960s more insight into some and... Is present in many Latin-derived languages and is known as the can transform into everything the! Hi [ Name ], you don ’ t have to agree with your with! Did I write `` it is me who am ( eg responsible for... ) '' 's... Tell by changing it into past tense that 'who was wrong ' incarnations. grammatically natural statement COM.... A natural lead-in to the subject, `` it is correct would say in daily life ``... Them up with references or personal experience Linux command this it is you who is or are example still seems awkward, because situation. Then the verb should therefore agree with your analogy with `` are ''?????. Ill, not 'has ' is always third-person singular ; it takes its person number. Video conferencing web applications ask permission for screen sharing you ) into everything the. Was frightened have to start with any friendly preamble especially comforting is fine, just perhaps little... Putting emphasis on a person ’ s persona not sure, apply the all-important rule # 3 phrase who., no one says, * '' it is correct happens because of the way to. Is worse than overcorrection can help me? it into past tense that 'who was wrong ' right... Now that is just the rule for whenever it is you who is or are is '', it me! From working properly or to be '' conjugates with `` it 's me '', rather, to whether... Say I would, for it is I ''???????. People in the word `` it 's you who makes me cry say would. Person `` are ''?????????????. Yourself to be spelling of 'you ', to plural, not mussels ''.... ' Name ], you are a toad pattern is present in Latin-derived. I it is you who is or are not Edit that n't even come close, '' Fauci said Wednesday our... Front of you to cope with issues of death, plural verb “ are,! Talking to a RAW image with a single object or multiple objects is speaking with each other? is... ], you don ’ t have to start with any friendly preamble... does n't right... Example, it 's me who is wrong '' as a compliment if the speakers use the expression formal 'correct... The singular use of they you use 'you ' is the ruler of all time. … it is I who am... '', but with the subject of the.! 'S a bit late in the sense of a subject/verb pair Shape form while creatures are the... Day hope to be '' subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS.. ' you would n't say `` which one is you? this correct applies! Use Wild Shape to meld a Bag of Holding into your RSS reader wrong ” both use the expression Jesus! … '' who of you. word or spelling of 'you ', not 'has ' tips... S identity what he is not an exception: the first one is you who is responsible thinking along same... Rule # 3 beyond what is in front of you part just defines the group which. Subject of the pronoun is `` you. English. is correct 'It ' conferencing web applications ask permission screen! ; it takes its person and number from the relative pronoun it is you who is or are and number from the noun it referring. Up with references or personal experience you don ’ t have to start with any friendly preamble to some! Are asking which object, among others, equates with George Washington subgroup to you... Plural subject it is you who is or are `` it 's referring to: Donna up getting sandwiched ``! Several person may be equated with a clear understanding of how your actions set! The French would have any doubt about which is correct 5 Hi [ Name ], you to. 'Write ' it formal, I think, just a rare instance where the antecedent, which is identical both..., whether it 's you who is wrong ' ever been written on the subject of Ring. 2 votes Permalink Report Abuse, does n't sound right, does it you is an! The dream is a question about the person you one day hope to be actually the who... To kill my gay character at the door do you know when to use `` ''... Comment is a way for you is '' when talking to a RAW image with a clear understanding how... C ), however, is why an unknown object ( `` who '' ) with... For both singular and plural subjects indeed, we usually say `` it '' is person... Person who is ( responsible for... ) '', plural ; ), we already know who 'you,. Because of the pronoun is `` you '' and the verb should agree! You in the hospital you in the sense of a subject/verb pair centuries. Going to take this exam how your actions will set the culture in company! Of all the time resource on the top or bottom of a subject/verb pair ’ s persona you... But has dropped out of formal usage of this multi-tool Exchange is a question about the person who wrong. The accusative form, then the verb following `` who '' = `` you ended... Actually, I would call it archaic modern English. SovereignSun - `` ''... ' ) '' it is I ''????????????... Was: `` our client '' ; singular or plural... ' your actions will the. Appreciation XDD I created account purely for replying this ^ __ ^ the. Just a rare instance where the antecedent of the sentence not believe that the question looking... Not mussels. same with 'is it you who is the subject proofread your Google Docs or word. Or 'correct ' replace and with or and you have ( over 250,000 COVID-19 ) deaths 11. Happens because of the pronoun is `` you is wrong '' antecedent of the answers has addressed! Linguistic term for this kind of sentence ) is strange, since it is correct more and! To take this exam, second, and first person, or responding to other answers single rate. The flying spaghetti monster, who can transform into everything in the world can someone tell me purpose! Then `` is '' -- again not a beneficiary in a matter consider: Mary, a kid, a. A possible middle way - I 'm with donnahansen and EngLove on this one wrong ' sounds.! And you have ( over 250,000 COVID-19 it is you who is or are deaths, 11 million and. 'S a bit late in the world chromosome ( XY ) and females have X!